Intimacy on the Internet: the wrong question for the right concern
With any given single function tool that can produce dichotomized end results, it is improper to ask if this tool promotes one result over another. One example of such tools is a light switch. If we ask the question, “does the light switch keep the room dark or lit?” we may be tempted at first to say naturally the light switch keeps the room lit, because it activates the lighting device in the room. However, we realize that the light switch is merely a tool to control the brightness of the room, and it can keep the room dark as proficiently as it keeps the room lit. In a similar way, the internet first served its function as an information/data disseminating tool. As entertainment, socialization, and other “off-the-clock” uses became entangled with the web, the effect of the internet invaded the personal lives of its users and operators. Enter the consideration of intimacy and the internet, two elements that the early internet architects most likely never imagined to be an issue. For the sake of discussion, we simplify the effect of the internet on intimacy into binomial outcomes of either uniting people together or driving people apart. Again, we encounter the familiar incompatibility of a tool promoting one result over another. What, then, determines the brightness of the room, or the enhancement or detriment of intimacy? Simply put, it is the choice of the user/operator of the tool that determines the end result, and the tool promotes neither of the outcomes.
I recognize that we may address the sociobehavioral trend of internet users, but that requires a very large and complex study to determine quantitatively how many internet users globally are utilizing the internet to hinder intimacy vs. enhancing it—which is not at our disposal. The question at hand stands to either condemn the internet for destroying intimacy or praise the internet for expanding the reaches of intimacy. These two conclusions, however, are invalid judgments to pass on the internet for the reason that the internet is a neutral tool, and cannot influence the preservation or loss of intimacy of human interaction. For instance, many users of online social website Facebook claim that the “ambient intimacy” created by the internet portal allows the users to “ʻfeel less alone’” thus effectively enhancing the intimacy of social interaction (New York Times). This perceived enhanced intimacy is measured by the increase in frequency of interaction via internet when a person is away from another. Having the ability to monitor the activities of your social kin online satisfies our need of connections to others as social creatures. Furthermore, the continuing rise in the population of singles using online dating services seems to suggest that the internet is facilitating one of the most intimate (as measured by physical interaction) processes of human nature: the seeking of a potentially life-long mate (Sautter et al., 20). This speaks volumes for the internet used as a tool to establish and propagate intimacy of the utmost, romantic degree.
As the previous examples have provided evidence of the internet being used to bring people together (either in spirit or in reality), there exists uses of the internet that drive people further apart. When the internet is used as a means to carry out routine friendly communications, it serves as a crutch to satisfy our need for social interaction in place of more intimate contact that may take place in person. The restoration of more intimate social behavior was observed by some when online interactions were forbidden (Experiment #9). Evidently, some individuals have slipped into using the internet as a convenient means of sustaining social relationships, which does indeed decrease the intimacy of those relations during that form of interaction. This suggests some internet users may be utilizing online interactions purposefully to reduce the intimacy of a social interaction (by choice). Moreover, in another form of online social encounter such as meeting a new individual, the intimacy of an open exchange between two unfamiliar persons when disclosing interests or attributes is stripped away and replaced by browsing self-biographies written in the “about me” sections of Facebook (Experiment #7). One of the closest interactions that can be experienced by two individuals through discovery of shared interests or attributes cannot be perceived through this form of online, one-way author-reader communication.
As evident by these cases of the internet both disrupting and preserving intimacy, we cannot conclude that the internet influences a net effect of uniting or disbanding people. Ultimately, the choice of the individuals is what drives people together or away from one another. The internet is merely a tool to exercise such a choice, as are other technological forms of communication. If it is one person’s wish to minimize intimacy with an acquaintance, he or she may communicate her wishes via internet to effectively disrupt that intimacy. However, if the person’s wish is to seek more intimate encounters with others, he or she may establish those desires through online interactions that lead to physical interactions. While the internet does potentially serve as a crutch to more intimate forms of social activities, the drive for social interaction is surely to overcome any perceived barrier to desired intimacy.
Works cited
Sautter, Jessica M., Rebecca M. Tippett, S. Philip Morgan. “The Social Demography of Internet Dating in the United States.” Social Science Quarterly 6 4 2010: 554-575.
Thompson, Clive. Brave New World of Digital Intimacy. 5 9 2008. 4 6 2010 .
Week 7 experiment: Facebook stalking.
Week 9 experiment: the differences in seeking happiness online and seeking happiness offline.